People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Amazing service and atmosphere. Top notch prep and presentation. The pie was perfect and literally the best shrimp I ever had at a restaurant. Will return and highly recommend! ”
“ Our son recommended Fantini's to us. We went tonight for my husband's birthday. We love everything about it; the food, the atmosphere, and the wait staff. Everyone was super friendly and accommodating. Our waiter, Chris, was personal, attentive and funny. We ordered the calamari and The Works. The portions were generous and the taste was worth the price. I'm sorry I didn't get pictures, but we were too busy being present enjoying our meal and evening. We will be back with family and friends. ”
“ Our first time here! Small and Intimate with a great atmosphere. Staff was pleasant and attentive. Even at 6 pm on a Saturday the food came out quickly and was amazing. The calamari was cooked perfectly, Deborah's Salmon with vodka sauce and fingerling potatoes looked delicious and I had the Beef Short Rib Lasagna which our waitress recommended left me speechless but not hungry. We will definitely be back. ”
“ Never disappoints. Great owner, great servers, Abbie is the best. Pizza is the best we’ve had in South Florida and is as good as any back home in Philly(home of the Super Bowl Champion Eagles!). Salads and entrees are also excellent. We love supporting local businesses when here for the winter and look forward to one more visit before heading home the end of March. ”
“ Had a great Italian meal here. They give generous portions that also taste great. We like the ricotta board to start along with the short rib, pasta and clams with linguine. The pizza is also fantastic. Give it a try if you’re in the area! ”
“ My husband is the pizza lover. For his bday last year, we dove from Tampa. I THOUGHT I could never eat pizza again, and I would be fine. And let me tell you, the 3.5 HOUR drive was definitely worth it!! This year, when he wanted to go again, I was so excited I offered to drive!!!! Hands down the best pizza ("apizza")I've ever had!!! Jimmy's Favorite is our favorite!!! Im wishing you much success at this new location. It was beautiful!! Amazing food, staff & atmosphere. ”
“ Pizza was excellent, salad was amazing, and Jessica, Vanessa, and Johnny took very good care of me at the bar. Can't recommend the Tomato Burrata salad enough. Also, some of the best meatball I have ever had. ”
“ Absolutely love this place. I love New Haven pizza and Jimmy really brought it to South Florida. My second time coming here and first time in their new location. The quality of the food is immaculate. Our waiter Chris was amazing and informative of whats on the menu. Amazing atmosphere they had a live band playing. Wasn’t too loud so we can talk. I will definitely be going back! ”
Menu
Beef Short Rib Arancini
US$16.00Linguine With Proscuitto & Mushrooms
Still Saratoga
Sparkling Saratoga
House Gelato
US$12.00
About
Fantini's Italian Restaurant featuring New Haven Style Apizza
If you find yourself near Stuart, FL, make your way to Fantini's Italian Restaurant featuring New Haven Style Apizza. This charming eatery, located at 1670 NW Federal Hwy, offers an authentic taste of Italian cuisine that captures the heart of New Haven's famed apizza tradition. With a cozy and intimate atmosphere, it's the perfect spot for a romantic dinner, a family gathering, or a casual night out with friends.
Fantini’s has quickly garnered a reputation for not just great food, but also incredible service. As echoed in numerous customer reviews, the staff go above and beyond to ensure guests feel welcomed. From the moment you step through the door, you are greeted with warmth and genuine hospitality. Chris, one of the standout waitstaff members, is noted for his personal, attentive, and humorous service, making dining here an experience rather than just a meal.
The menu features an array of dishes that are both generous in portion and exquisite in taste. Patrons rave about the delicious calamari, expertly cooked to tender perfection. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the Beef Short Rib Lasagna stands out, leaving a lasting impression as one of the most satisfying lasagnas you’ll ever have. The seafood dishes, such as the shrimp, consistently receive high praise for being fresh and flavorful.
Of course, no visit to Fantini's would be complete without indulging in their exquisite apizza. Reviewers have declared it to be the best in South Florida, rivaling even legendary pizza spots back in Philadelphia. The crust is perfectly crisp, and the toppings are vibrant and fresh, providing a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate.
Many diners find themselves lost in the moment, too immersed in the delightful food and inviting atmosphere to snap photos. This speaks volumes about the experience that Fantini’s provides; it’s about savoring every bite and enjoying the company around you. With generous portions, fantastic flavors, and an ambiance that encourages lingering, it's not hard to see why guests return time and again.
For an unforgettable Italian meal that feels like a warm hug, look no further than Fantini's Italian Restaurant. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this is one dining experience you shouldn’t miss. Call them at +1 772-692-9980 to make a reservation today, and prepare to be wowed!
Book a table